Week 10 Fantasy Football: Start 'Em, Sit 'Em – J.J. McCarthy vs. Kirk Cousins
Fantasy football managers facing a quarterback dilemma in Week 10 received a detailed breakdown comparing New York Giants rookie J.J. McCarthy and veteran Kirk Cousins. The analysis, published November 12, 2026, comes on the heels of McCarthy's start against the Philadelphia Eagles at Lincoln Financial Field on November 8.
McCarthy's Week 10 Outlook
McCarthy, wearing No. 18 for the Giants, looked to pass against a tough Eagles defense in the first quarter of the Philadelphia matchup. His performance in that game provides the primary data point for fantasy evaluators considering whether to start the rookie signal-caller.
Cousins as the Benchmark
The start/sit column uses Cousins as the comparative veteran presence, weighing his established track record against McCarthy's upside and recent game action. The piece aims to guide fantasy owners on which quarterback offers the safer floor and which presents the higher ceiling for the critical mid-season week.
Nick Raducanu authored the fantasy football analysis for Sports Illustrated's fantasy vertical.


