Why Carson Benge Deserved NL Rookie of the Year Over Sal Stewart, Argues Columnist
Andrew Tredinnick makes the case that New York Mets right fielder Carson Benge should have won the 2026 National League Rookie of the Year award instead of Cincinnati Reds first baseman Sal Stewart. Stewart won the honor with 20 of 30 first-place votes, leading all NL rookies with 32 home runs and 112 RBI, but Tredinnick argues Benge's all-around performance over the full 162-game season warranted the top spot.
Benge finished as runner-up with seven first-place votes. After a slow start in April (.189 average, .525 OPS), he slashed .299/.363/.457 over the final five months. He led all NL rookies with 168 hits, ranked second in batting average (.282) and home runs (20), third in RBI (65) and stolen bases (22), and was the only NL rookie to finish in the top three in each of those key offensive categories. His 118 OPS+ surpassed both Stewart and St. Louis Cardinals second baseman JJ Wetherholt, who placed third in voting.
Defensively, Benge was one of three finalists for the NL Gold Glove in right field. He recorded 10 outfield assists (third-most among NL outfielders), 7 defensive runs saved, and posted the best arm value in baseball with the fifth-highest arm strength in MLB. Stewart, by contrast, posted a -2 outs above average at first base, while Wetherholt excelled defensively with a +25 outs above average at second base.
Tredinnick contends that Benge provided the best combination of offense and defense among the rookie class, and that his strong finish over the season's final two months demonstrated the endurance required for a 162-game campaign. The Mets also saw Nolan McLean finish fourth in the voting and A.J. Ewing receive a fifth-place vote, signaling a promising future for the organization.



