Five NFL Moves Teams Should Regret at the 2026 Season's Midpoint
Past the midway point of the 2026 NFL season, several offseason decisions already look like costly mistakes that could haunt franchises for years. Here are five moves that teams should deeply regret.
Indianapolis Colts: Signing Daniel Jones to an $88 Million Contract
The Colts re-signed Daniel Jones in March rather than using the franchise or transition tag, a move criticized immediately. Jones entered 2026 with a career 70-47 touchdown-to-interception ratio, an 84.3 passer rating, and a 24-44-1 record in 70 games from 2019–2024. General manager Chris Ballard was swayed by an eight-game stretch where Jones went 7-1 with a 71.2% completion rate, 13-3 TD-INT, and a 109.5 passer rating. Ballard even traded two first-round picks for cornerback Sauce Gardner, believing Jones was a franchise quarterback. Jones then went 1-4 in his final five games of 2025 with a 6-5 TD-INT line and an 84.2 rating before tearing his Achilles. Indianapolis still signed him to an $88 million deal, a decision that contributed to Ballard's firing.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers: Caving to Baker Mayfield with a $165 Million Extension
After a 2025 season in which Mayfield played through a shoulder injury and posted a 3-8 record, 80.6 passer rating, 14-10 TD-INT, and 195.8 passing yards per game in his final 11 starts, the Buccaneers signed him to a three-year, $165 million extension on September 8 with $110 million in new guarantees. Since then, Tampa Bay is 1-4 in games Mayfield has completed a pass, and he owns a 60.6% completion rate, 2.1% touchdown rate, 6.5 yards per attempt, a 74.9 passer rating, and a -1.5% Completion Rate Over Expectation. At age 31, his cap hit nearly doubles next season from $34 million to $65.7 million.
Los Angeles Chargers: Hiring Mike McDaniel as Offensive Coordinator
The Chargers' offense has been historically bad under McDaniel. Entering Week 10, they rank last in EPA per play at -0.219 (Minnesota is 31st at -0.156), are one of only two teams with fewer than 20 red-zone trips, and have a scoring rate under 30%. They endured a streak of 37 consecutive drives without an offensive touchdown. The starting quarterback's career interception rate of 1.7% has more than doubled to 4.7% in 2026, and his passer rating has plummeted from 96.3 to 70.4. While not solely McDaniel's fault, the play-caller deserves the majority of the blame.
Arizona Cardinals: Using the Third Overall Pick on Jeremiyah Love
Love was considered the best running back in the 2026 draft and a potential Rookie of the Year. However, he is currently on injured reserve with his third different ankle injury since joining the Cardinals. In six games played, he topped 65 rushing yards only once, averaged under 3.5 yards per carry in three games, had two or fewer receptions in four games, and never reached 20 receiving yards. Meanwhile, later-round backs like Kaelon Black (90th overall), Mike Washington Jr. (122nd), and others are outproducing him. Arizona risks ruining a generational talent.
Minnesota Vikings: Quarterback Mismanagement
The Vikings traded former first-round pick J.J. McCarthy to the New York Giants for a fifth-round pick in late September; McCarthy has looked serviceable since. Head coach Kevin O'Connell apparently wanted nothing to do with him, and the team instead signed Kyler Murray for the veteran minimum and rolled with a quarterback room of Murray and Carson Wentz. The result is a wasted once-in-a-decade defense. Given O'Connell's reputation as a "quarterback whisperer," the Vikings might be better off promoting defensive coordinator Brian Flores to head coach this offseason.



