Raiders Rookie Fernando Mendoza Faces Historical Odds in First Start Against Seahawks
Las Vegas Raiders rookie quarterback Fernando Mendoza, the No. 1 overall pick in April's draft, will make his first NFL start on Sunday against the Seattle Seahawks after the team traded veteran Kirk Cousins to Minnesota for a third-round pick. The Raiders enter the game with a 4-5 record, mirroring the situation two previous teams faced when turning to a rookie quarterback at midseason.
In 2016, the Los Angeles Rams were 4-5 when they benched Case Keenum for Jared Goff; Goff lost all seven starts, throwing five touchdowns and seven interceptions as the Rams finished 4-12. Two years later, the Baltimore Ravens were also 4-5 when Lamar Jackson replaced an injured Joe Flacco; Jackson won six of his first seven starts, leading Baltimore to the AFC North title. Same record, same point in the season, two completely different outcomes.
Since 2000, 148 quarterbacks have started at least one game as rookies. Only 22 made their first start between Weeks 10 and 13, and their collective debuts were poor: 53.8% completion rate, 5.8 yards per attempt, 5.3% interception rate, and a 22.7% win rate — the worst marks of any group. Just five of those 22 won their first start, and their interception rate was more than 1.6 times that of rookies who started in Week 1.
Team performance before and after inserting a rookie in Weeks 10-13 shows limited improvement. Five teams with winning records went from a combined 30-19 to 10-20 (33.3% win rate) after the change. Seventeen teams with losing records improved slightly from a 28.9% win rate to 33.7%, but still lost twice as often as they won. Only three of the 22 teams reached the playoffs: the 2011 Houston Texans (T.J. Yates), the 2017 Buffalo Bills (Nathan Peterman, who threw five interceptions in a half), and the 2018 Ravens (Jackson).
Mendoza's early schedule offers no relief. His first three starts come against Seattle, Denver, and Cleveland — three of the league's top defenses. The schedule eases after a Week 13 bye, though matchups against the Broncos and Chiefs remain in the final four games.
The Raiders' problems extend beyond quarterback. Despite Cousins throwing 20 touchdowns and eight interceptions while averaging 25.4 points per game, Las Vegas ranks last in yards per carry (2.9), 31st in rushing yards per game (71.3), and 30th in rushing success rate. The defense has allowed 35.7 points per game over the last six weeks, with five losses in that span.
An earlier projection for Mendoza estimated a 61.4% completion rate, 6.6 yards per attempt, and an 82.1 passer rating, but noted he landed in the least quarterback-friendly situation among rookies. As with Goff and Jackson, both of whom eventually became elite quarterbacks, Mendoza's immediate record may not reflect his long-term potential. His task is to prove he belongs; the organization's task is to build a supporting cast that gives him a chance to succeed.



