College Football Playoff Formula Criticized as Flawed
USA TODAY columnist Matt Hayes argues that the current college football playoff system encourages teams to schedule weak opponents, win a minimal number of games, and rely on luck to reach the postseason.
In a column published November 16, 2026, Hayes describes the formula as a joke, suggesting that programs can play nobody, win eight games, and pray for a playoff berth.
The criticism highlights ongoing debates about the fairness and competitiveness of the playoff selection process.



