Buyer Beware: Five 2026 NFL Trade Deadline Deals Risk Becoming Next Sauce Gardner Bust
As in-season trades become more prevalent in the NFL, the risk of overspending rises. That was most clear in 2025 when the Indianapolis Colts sent two first-round picks to the New York Jets for cornerback Sauce Gardner, a deal now regarded as perhaps the most regrettable in league history. The Colts are in a deep rebuild while Gardner has played the worst football of his career since arriving in Indianapolis. With 18 deals completed ahead of the 2026 trade deadline, teams hope to avoid a similar disaster. Only one transaction this year included two first-round picks, and it is already paying dividends for the acquiring side.
Jeffery Simmons to Bears
The trade most resembling the Gardner deal moved defensive tackle Jeffery Simmons to the Chicago Bears, with the Tennessee Titans securing two first-round picks. Simmons has delivered immediately, notching a sack and pass breakup in each of his first two games and adding a tackle for loss in his debut. He has elevated the entire unit, and early indications suggest the trade is a slam dunk for the Super Bowl-contending Bears.
Jordan Davis to Jaguars
Jacksonville sent a 2027 first-round pick and a 2029 second-rounder to acquire defensive tackle Jordan Davis, filling the void left by DaVon Hamilton's season-ending torn quad. The Jaguars are in contention for the AFC's No. 1 seed, and the trade will be judged by Davis's postseason impact. While he should replace Hamilton's run-stopping, his pass-rush ceiling (never more than 4.5 sacks in a season) raises questions about whether the price was an overpay.
Marvin Harrison Jr. to Texans
The 2023 Biletnikoff Award winner, already considered a bust as the No. 4 overall pick, was traded from the Arizona Cardinals to the Houston Texans for a second-round pick. Reunited with college quarterback C.J. Stroud, Harrison has yet to catch more than three passes in a game over three appearances, all off the bench, and has run only 29 routes. With a crowded receiver room including Nico Collins, Tank Dell, and tight end Dalton Schultz (team-leading 47 targets), Harrison's role remains uncertain.
Kirk Cousins to Vikings
Minnesota acquired quarterback Kirk Cousins from the Las Vegas Raiders for a third-round pick, hoping he can elevate an offense paired with an elite defense. Cousins thrived in Raiders coach Klint Kubiak's system, on pace for a potential 40-touchdown season. However, at 38 and coming off an Achilles tear, his performance outside that scheme is unproven. His previous stint under Vikings coach Kevin O'Connell produced a Pro Bowl season, but the current version of Cousins is different from the one who won 13 games in 2022.
Joey Porter Jr. to Cowboys
Dallas traded a 2028 second-round pick and a 2027 sixth-rounder for cornerback Joey Porter Jr. on Oct. 1. He has missed multiple games due to illness and an ankle injury, recording no statistics in his only full game. When healthy, Porter is a lockdown corner, allowing a passer rating no higher than 47.9 across 10 targets in his first three games. Yet his availability and contract demands (the Steelers refused to make him one of the highest-paid corners) could turn this into a one-year rental for a defense that remains the NFL's third-worst in yards allowed per game.
Quenton Nelson to Seahawks
Seattle sent a 2027 third-round pick and a 2028 fifth-rounder for All-Pro guard Quenton Nelson on Oct. 27. Nelson underwent a minor knee procedure and is week-to-week, missing Week 10 but not placed on injured reserve. Before the surgery, he did not immediately improve the running game (81 yards in his debut, 3.6 yards per carry last week). The trade's value hinges on Nelson returning to full strength and potentially re-signing in free agency.



