2025 NFL Draft Class Mid-Season Review: Bounce-Backs and Letdowns
Articles · 21:49:07 - Saturday, 21 November 2026
Articles

2025 NFL Draft Class Mid-Season Review: Bounce-Backs and Letdowns

Halfway through their second NFL seasons, the 2025 first-round picks are facing a critical evaluation point. A year and a half provides enough sample size to judge whether most top selections are on track to meet expectations, with contract extensions looming for early producers and potential early free agency for those who continue to disappoint.

Bounce-back candidates

Quarterback Cam Ward of the Tennessee Titans shows signs of progress. Over his last two games, Ward posted a personal-best 304 passing yards against the Cincinnati Bengals and a 71.8% completion rate against the Jacksonville Jaguars, achieving this without rookie receiver Carnell Tate. His pressure rate and sack numbers have improved, and head coach Robert Saleh noted a philosophical shift to give Ward more opportunity to prove he can be the franchise quarterback. Ward's first 25 starts compare closely to those of Trevor Lawrence, who needed a similar onramp before becoming a top passer.

Two-way player Travis Hunter of the Jaguars has flourished after a torn LCL cut short his rookie year. In 2026, Hunter ranks 11th league-wide among cornerbacks by PFF defensive grade, allowing a 52.8 passer rating on 35 targets with three interceptions — tied for 10th among defensive backs with at least 20 targets. He also recorded a touchdown reception and an interception in the same game in Week 6, a feat achieved only five times since the merger.

Offensive tackle Will Campbell of the New England Patriots has quietly improved despite a rough outing against the Detroit Lions where he allowed six pressures and two sacks, one of which injured quarterback Drake Maye. Before that game, Campbell's pressure rate allowed (5.9%) led the team and ranked fourth among tackles with at least 100 pass blocks. His season pressure rate (7.0%) and sacks allowed (2.5) are down from 11.2% and 8.5 as a rookie.

Wide receiver Matthew Golden of the Green Bay Packers has exploded in his second year, surpassing his rookie 361-yard total in just five weeks. Through Week 10, Golden ranks fifth in the NFL with 853 receiving yards and is one of only three receivers with over 100 targets, alongside CeeDee Lamb and Jaxon Smith-Njigba. He forms a potent duo with Christian Watson, both ranking in the top seven in receiving yards per game.

Defensive tackle Tyleik Williams has become a fixture for the Detroit Lions, helping the unit climb from the bottom 10 in rush EPA per play allowed to the top 10. Williams is one of just 10 defensive linemen with at least 100 run-defense snaps who has not missed a tackle this season, per Next Gen Stats. Cornerback Maxwell Hairston of the Buffalo Bills has also outperformed his rookie year, posting the lowest completion percentage allowed among Bills defensive backs targeted at least 10 times and a -18.5% completion percentage over expectation, second-best in the NFL among defensive backs with 20-plus targets.

Letdowns

Running back Ashton Jeanty of the Las Vegas Raiders has regressed significantly. After a Heisman finalist season at Boise State, Jeanty's 41% rushing success rate and 975 yards with five touchdowns as a rookie were underwhelming. In 2026, his production has dropped further: 123 carries for 380 yards and one touchdown, while ceding playing time to rookie Mike Washington Jr. The Raiders' offensive line struggles (league-low 1.5 yards before contact per rush) share blame, but Jeanty's -46 rushing yards over expected in his first eight games ranked 123rd among 132 backs.

Fellow running back Omarion Hampton of the Los Angeles Chargers has seen per-game and per-touch production decline across the board. His rush yards per attempt fell from 4.4 to 3.6, rush yards per game from 60.6 to 46.1, receiving success rate from 51.4% to 38.5%, and receiving yards per game from 21.3 to 7.9. Hampton's -46 rushing yards over expected in his first eight games also ranked near the bottom.

Edge rusher Mykel Williams of the San Francisco 49ers has played only 14 career games due to a torn ACL and has 2.5 sacks. He has not played more than half the defensive snaps in any game this season, and his average time to pressure (3.69 seconds) ranks tied for 15th-longest among 191 defensive linemen with 50-plus pass-rush snaps. The 49ers acquired DeForest Buckner at the trade deadline, who in two games nearly matched Williams' snap count and equaled his quick pressures.

Cincinnati Bengals edge rusher Shemar Stewart has seen his role shrink dramatically. After five starts as a rookie, Stewart has just 52 defensive snaps in 2026, with multiple healthy scratches. Outside of a Week 2 sack in five snaps, he has zero pressures, zero sacks, and one tackle assist over his last five games. The Bengals signed Boye Mafe in free agency and drafted Cashius Howell, who already has a sack and 12 pressures, further marginalizing the former No. 17 pick.

With contract decisions approaching, the divergence between bounce-back players and letdowns will shape roster construction for years to come.

Share this article: