Gotham FC Moves NWSL Semifinal to Icahn Stadium Over Pitch Safety Concerns
Gotham FC has relocated its NWSL playoff semifinal against the Kansas City Current from Sports Illustrated Stadium in Harrison, New Jersey, to Icahn Stadium on Manhattan's Randall's Island due to concerns over pitch quality and player safety. The decision came roughly 24 hours after Gotham's 1-0 quarterfinal win over the Seattle Reign, during which coach Juan Carlos Amoros apologized for the state of the playing surface.
The pitch at Sports Illustrated Stadium, which has historically been rated among the best in American soccer, showed visible deterioration after hosting a USA Rugby Fall Series doubleheader on October 30. Sand residue and faint rugby lines remained on the field, prompting criticism from players and coaches. Reign head coach Laura Harvey described the surface as "s---", captain Jess Fishlock called it "atrocious", and Gotham midfielder Jaelin Howell labeled it "sandy" and "unstable". Despite a field consultant deeming the pitch compliant with FIFA standards, the NWSL fined Gotham $10,000 for the field conditions, even though the club does not manage the venue as a secondary tenant to MLS side Red Bull New York (RBNY).
Discussions between Gotham, the NWSL, and RBNY explored options such as re-sodding or a hybrid grass-artificial reinforcement, but RBNY declined due to a scheduled friendly against Club America on Saturday. The NWSL could not guarantee the work would be completed in time for that match. Consequently, Gotham opted to move to Icahn Stadium, a 5,000-seat venue where they have played twice previously. Captain Tierna Davidson acknowledged the difficulty of the move, noting that a smaller stadium means many fans will be unable to attend.
Broader logistical challenges for the NWSL
The last-minute venue change highlights ongoing logistical struggles for the NWSL, where roughly half the teams are secondary tenants in stadiums controlled by MLS clubs. Scheduling conflicts with MLS matches have forced multiple teams to relocate games this season. Gotham will leave Sports Illustrated Stadium for Etihad Park in 2028, but will remain a secondary tenant under New York City FC. The league continues to grapple with calendar alignment and venue control as it expands, with teams like the Kansas City Current, who own and operate CPKC Stadium, serving as a potential model for future stability.



